Mod´s, please allowed MP4 video to trade on TTD

we need a change (upgrade?) with the rules!!!
old shitty VHS transfer is allowed, but not really fucking good quality MP4 video!
please, MOD´s, god´s of TTD, allowed it!!!

[daddyray]

I strongly agree

mp4 are good

please
pretty please

[uni-fi]

I say neigh...Would the MP4 rip of that same shitty VHS be as good as the uncompressed rip of said shitty VHS?

Nope.

The same goes for the good quality MP4 releases...there is a better, uncompressed version of the master floating around somewhere.



I agree that MP4 is good, but it is still compressed.

[daddyray]

then add a contract clause to the upload

uni-fi, at first i mean ripped streams! do you ever saw a video from (example!) arte.de/fr???
the quality is real good!

by the way, some uploaded video with vhs/beta base are real shit! uncompressed shit!!!!

i think, allowed GOOD MP4 video to upload, anybody can say "I want it or no"

[uni-fi]

Or use a different tracker...



stamp out hope

[dcbullet]

I think this should go in site suggestions.

Originally Posted by uni-fi

Or use a different tracker...



stamp out hope

yeah, i use dime, but that´s not what i want
if quality the point, a lot of the older tape transfer must forbidden!
some user mean a crackling (?) noisy tape as dvd is better???????????????????

example
have a lot of older punk stuff from the ramones / dead kenndys where uploaded on tracker sites, but it´s a shame to show anybody this shit
this uncompressed shit is better as real good MP4???????

[paddington]

Originally Posted by uni-fi

I say neigh...Would the MP4 rip of that same shitty VHS be as good as the uncompressed rip of said shitty VHS?

Nope.

The same goes for the good quality MP4 releases...there is a better, uncompressed version of the master floating around somewhere.



I agree that MP4 is good, but it is still compressed.

Are you thinking of MP4 audio or something?

'cause all video traded here at TTD is compressed.

Uncompressed video is enormous in size.

DVDs? Allowed. Compressed MP2 video with various audio encodings.
VHS transfer to DVD? Allowed.
Blu-Rays? Allowed...

BluRays contain the same h.264-encoded video found in most modern MP4-wrapped files.


MP4 should definitely be allowed, in my opinion but, some discussion is warranted as to what kind of MP4 we'll allow.

MP4 is a wrapper... the codec inside can be h.264, which is nearly all HD video these days. h.264 has several profiles associated which can be used when encoding - everything from medium quality for tiny screens and devices all the way up to ludicrous quality that hardly any storage medium can hold.

We need to make a decision as to what sort of video in the MP4 shall be allowed and roll with that.

For example, we might not allow all "MP4", as a blanket but we might allow the h.264 codec, profiles 4 and up, in an MP4 wrapper.

[harpsichord]

Compressed shit is like constipation, right?

(C'mon, you knew somebody was gonna mention it)

Originally Posted by jameskg

Are you thinking of MP4 audio or something?

'cause all video traded here at TTD is compressed.

Uncompressed video is enormous in size.

DVDs? Allowed. Compressed MP2 video with various audio encodings.
VHS transfer to DVD? Allowed.
Blu-Rays? Allowed...

BluRays contain the same h.264-encoded video found in most modern MP4-wrapped files.


MP4 should definitely be allowed, in my opinion but, some discussion is warranted as to what kind of MP4 we'll allow.

MP4 is a wrapper... the codec inside can be h.264, which is nearly all HD video these days. h.264 has several profiles associated which can be used when encoding - everything from medium quality for tiny screens and devices all the way up to ludicrous quality that hardly any storage medium can hold.

We need to make a decision as to what sort of video in the MP4 shall be allowed and roll with that.

For example, we might not allow all "MP4", as a blanket but we might allow the h.264 codec, profiles 4 and up, in an MP4 wrapper.

the sort of MP4 Video streams, please!

[jabulon]

Folks should realize that MP4 video-streams are mainly designed for computer use and that the video frame sizes used can vary greatly, so playback on a dvd-player could be a hassle if not impossible (because many DVD players only support a few video frame sizes). This is one of the reasons why I advise people to buy a streamer nowadays.

[daddyray]

free the MP4s

Free Pussy Riot!