PDA

View Full Version : Lossy Digital-sourced radio sample?


GRC
2007-07-20, 05:52 AM
From UK Digital Freeview service - can someone spectrally inspect and report back? Trying to establish if I can upload...

Regards, Graham

pawel
2007-07-20, 08:27 AM
Nothing to inspect, IMO. All (big/commercial) radios are lossy nowadays - terrestrial broadcasts are also very compressed and very often over saturated to be more 'loud'.

Edit: I'd prefer that a digital capture is seeded in native format: MP2 or AC3. Conversion to WAV>FLAC doubles their lossiness and size.

GRC
2007-07-20, 09:05 AM
Nothing to inspect, IMO. All (big/commercial) radios are lossy nowadays - terrestrial broadcasts are also very compressed and very often over saturated to be more 'loud'.

Edit: I'd prefer that a digital capture is seeded in native format: MP2 or AC3. Conversion to WAV>FLAC doubles their lossiness and size.


So, no FM broadcasts, at TTD, then, if all radio is lossy........? There's a torrent category for them.....

I'd love to get a pure digital stream, but the digibox outputs either analogue, via 2 x RCA phono L/R, or 48kHz PCM via single RCA phono. All of my radio captures these days go onto my Alesis Masterlink @<hidden> 48kHz, and get archived to CDR with sample rate conversion by the Alesis to 44.1kHz. Everyone recommends EAC, which stores the files as .WAVs, and .FLAC or .SHN are the preferred files for torrents, so I HAVE to convert WAVs to FLACs .... No? :hmm:

Any FM tuners out there will only output an analogue signal via 2 x RCA phono L/R, so those will have to be D/A converted to start with.....

Do you have any recommendations for gear that does output mp2 or AC3?

Regards, Graham

pawel
2007-07-20, 12:27 PM
When you wrote "Digital Service" I thought about digital taping as well, for example via a DVB (S/C/T) card or a PVR recorder - both capture and output in native broadcast format.

I think most BBC channels, except HD service, broadcast in MP2, and no higher rate than 192 kbps. So, what you get from your digibox is lossy and converted to wav.

GRC
2007-07-20, 12:59 PM
Darn. I thought it sounded pretty good.

Regards, Graham

GRC
2007-07-20, 03:03 PM
Kind of leaves me between a rock and a hard place; there was a Jeff Beck show uploaded here recently - a pre-FM of the Radio 1 In Concert, but 1 track was missing. I've got that track, but sourced from a Digital Radio Broadcast.

On one hand, it should be uploaded to allow those who got the partial show to fill the gap. :)

However, if rules is rules....... the folks will have to do without :( :nono:

Regards, Graham