mp3 or MD sourced?

[mrright]

Hi,

I need a little help on this one.

2 seconds spectral anal. and frequency analysis attached.

Thanx in advance. :)

[mrright]

Here's a better looking picture of the freq analysis

[Five]

I'm leaning towards md but can't really say for sure since eac is terrible for spectral analysis

check over here
http://www.thetradersden.org/forums/showthread.php?t=4288

also post a 10-20 second sample via rapidshare.de / yousendit.com so we can look & listen

[mrright]

thanx for your response

here (http://rapidshare.de/files/23690137/Track02cut.wav.html) is a 20 sec sample

[mrright]

the show is from 1999

[slimeruky]

This show looks like MD to me. I do not see the typical flatness that occurs with mp3 and I see some particular upturn in the blocky parapets, good examples of this in the 2 second view attached.

[Five]

looks like md as far as I can see, too. perhaps lp4... very very low quality md (in fact, the lowest!).

[mrright]

looks like md as far as I can see, too. perhaps lp4... very very low quality md (in fact, the lowest!).

that's a shame with the low quality. :mad:

I have to thank you both very much for the help. :thumbsup

[calvin1663]

yeah...seems like a crummy md...sorry you got a bad one :(