View Full Version : 1st show from 85

2006-03-15, 12:43 PM
Hey all , im looking for a few opinions on these 2 1985 shows.
Going by the Freq analysis both would be a safe bet to have mp3 in the lineage , But looking at the 2 sec closeup things change.There are neither holes or the floating Blocks.

2006-03-15, 02:47 PM
While the other one is "iffy", this one looks fine. Again, get a second opinion.

EDIT: I should have said before that I'm not 100% how much music is actually here because it seems to be buried in a lot of hiss.

2006-03-15, 02:57 PM
like you say, no direct evidence since there's no blocks. strange that it cuts off so abruptly at about 16kHz.

if you can up a 10-20second FLAC sample I would like to have a closer look and listen (use yousendit.com / rapidshare.de)

2006-03-16, 08:00 AM
Could you please up a flac sample?

2006-03-16, 10:35 AM
mp3, I'm pretty sure. mp3 encoders usually don't waste bits above 16kHz (remember, it's disproportionately expensive) if these frequencies are masked by loud music in the lower ranges anyway.

(also looks like a subtly uneven cutoff to me)

2006-03-16, 10:57 AM
Actually you know what......I would really love in this case to see a black and white spectral view. That make the lows come out a bit darker so you can see through all of that hiss.

2006-03-16, 12:39 PM
Short sample here


2006-03-16, 12:49 PM
Good thing we got a hold of that sample.

This is 100% lossy.

1.) Just listen to it. It sounds like an mp3.
2.) The frequency analysis is so obvious, it's not even funny. :disbelief

2006-03-16, 01:59 PM
Yeah the Freq analysis is as i posted originaly.As i first posted the Freq and Spectral both scream mp3 , but its the 2 sec close up that doesnt show what you would expect to see , namely the blockiness and holes..........

2006-03-16, 02:45 PM
^that's exactly how I see it.

I looked at it in b&w zoomed to 2 seconds and scrolled thru the entire sample in this view looking for lego to no avail. I also listened to it and didn't hear hear the swish on the cymbals that normally tips me off. The cutoff is steep as hell (as we already knew) and in about the right place for this to be 32kHz DAT, but it looks too straight to be 32kHz DAT, in that case the "haircut" would have some stubble.

There is something very fishy with this one but I cannot find any direct evidence of lossy encoding here. I would continue to seek an alternate source and only trade this show one-on-one with others & including this information about the suspicious nature of the FA/SA.

here is a b&w SA showing the closest thing to blocks I could find along the top there.

2006-03-16, 02:49 PM
hey man can you post another sample which has a lot of cymbals on it? I'd like to have a listen to that if its not too much trouble.

2006-03-17, 11:18 AM
Evidence enough for me to think that it's mp3...

2006-03-17, 11:50 AM
good eye

thanks for finding that

this is mp3

seek thee a new & better source

2006-03-17, 12:38 PM
Evidence enough for me to think that it's mp3...

Thats wierd , Ive zoomed in to the same place and cant see the holes.

2006-03-17, 01:18 PM
try switching it from that green to deault (F4 to get to the settings)