[jdawson]

if you have dvd decrypter, have you tried ripping it as an ISO and burning it that way? I have one or two dvd's that that is the only way I can rip them. same deal, reads fine, ripping just doesn't happen unless it's in ISO.

Also, try running it through CD check and see if it comes up with any kind of errors. cd check is freeware, and it will rip it. If there are errors you will get a log-file telling you what it ran into. also it will repeatedly try and read that sector to get at least one clean pull.