[showtaper]

Originally Posted by KoolKat

How did you work out that mpeg 1 is DvD compliant.
Read what you wrote chap

The file in the torrent was listed as MPEG-1 352 x 240
and you've already said
352 × 240 pixels MPEG-1 (Same as the VCD Standard)

basically it was an authored VCD that WILL play in a DvD player as a DvD ,dont get me wrong,but only because of the 352 as THAT is DvD compliant.Half of 704 which is a cropped DvD Standard as well

But the torrent was still mpeg 1 which is NOT a DvD standard its a VCD standard.

With me

So it would be pulled...but definatly now that you add the extra info with it being official whether it was DvD,VCD or even a cup of Brooke Bond D Tea

K_K

352 × 240 pixels MPEG-1 (Same as the VCD Standard) is DVD compliant.
Please spend two seconds and look up the specification. All the formats
listed in my previous post are DVD COMPLIANT.

Whether or not it looks like shit is a completely different issue.

I couldn't look at the posters files as the thread is locked. Try reading
his comments, he took a DVD compliant MPEG-1 file and AUTHORED
a DVD from it. Read what someone else wrote, chap.

Personally, I have a line feed recording of this broadcast (provided by a
friend at Chrysalis records) which includes footage not broadcast, so I'm
not really interested in this torrent, just the bogus reason for its removal.

BTW - this was never released as an official VCD. Portions have been
included on official videocassette and DVD. You don't need anything more
than a quick google to figure this out.........