PDA

View Full Version : Is this ok to seed?


beeerlover
2007-06-25, 06:46 PM
Hi, curious is this is ok to seed or not:

http://bardfresh.free.fr/LiveAid/
& more specifically, this one (http://bardfresh.free.fr/LiveAid/pages00-23.jpg) which gives more specific details.

It appears there is 50 minutes of official DVD footage available for Live Aid, but this Box Set of 19 CDs does not use it-- do I still need to remove the songs that are also on the dvd?

U2Lynne
2007-06-25, 07:41 PM
One minute you say the show does not have official stuff, but then you ask about if you should remove it? :hmm:

If it is the exact same stuff on an official release, then you should remove it prior to seeding. Usually people still list the tracks in the setlist and then put a "*" after the song and then write at the end "* - song is official released. you can buy it on amazon.com under the name xxxxx" or something like that.

beeerlover
2007-06-25, 09:19 PM
You didnt understand the question.... but thats ok I'll not bother ya with it again.

Five
2007-06-26, 02:14 AM
the complete audio version of live aid is okay so long as it does not source the official dvd directly and the lineage jives with the audio bit torrent seeding requrements here (mainly best known source). I believe this is the one that was on STG before, correct?

complete DVD version is also okay so long as it takes nothing from the official set directly and has a reason to exist (mainly unavailable as an official release).

beeerlover
2008-06-04, 09:11 AM
the complete audio version of live aid is okay so long as it does not source the official dvd directly and the lineage jives with the audio bit torrent seeding requrements here (mainly best known source). I believe this is the one that was on STG before, correct?

complete DVD version is also okay so long as it takes nothing from the official set directly and has a reason to exist (mainly unavailable as an official release).


A year later, lol ... I forgot about this post.

Yes, been on STG before I am pretty sure.
I'll hunt up my data disks and see if all is still intact & perhaps get it seeded in the next day or so.